Tennessee Supreme Court holds economic loss doctrine does not bar jury’s $3.9M punitive damages award in contractor-subcontractor dispute. In Commercial Painting Co. v. Weitz Co. LLC, 676 S.W.3d 527 (Tenn. Sept. 27, 2023), the Tennessee Supreme Court considered whether the economic loss doctrine applied to claims other than products liability. The economic loss doctrine traditionally precludes recovery in tort for … Read More
Court Rules for Subcontractor in Corporate Veil Piercing, Fraudulent Conveyance Appeal
Trial Court Erred in Awarding Directed Verdict for Undercapitalized Contractor Defendant The recently decided Ruben Estrada v. DJ Exteriors, LLC et al. (2023 Tenn. App. LEXIS 91) involves a contractual dispute between a contractor and subcontractor. DJ Exteriors, LLC, a limited liability company specializing in masonry, siding, and roofing, was owned by three members – Dustin Jones, James Reedy, and … Read More
Economic Loss Rule Applied to Commercial Construction Contracts
The economic loss rule bars tort claims arising under construction contracts negotiated between sophisticated commercial entities. For years, the economic loss rule (or economic loss doctrine) has applied to limit a claimant to its contractual remedies and bar tort claims for purely economic loss. In fact, the Tennessee Supreme Court recently held in Milan Supply Chain Sols. v. Navistar that: … Read More